The Low Down on Processed Pet Foods

Cats and Dogs
August 27, 2016

The Low Down on Processed Pet Foods

The Low Down on Processed Pet Foods

Whats in my dogs kibble?

Meat protein is the most expensive component in pet food. Commercial pet food industries need to maximise profit, so how do they do this when the cost of meat is high? The answer is they incorporate high levels of carbs such as corn, wheat, rice and potato in their pet food. Protein is then added in the form of cheap, plant-based proteins such as soy, pea protein etc. Dogs and cats eating these processed foods struggle to properly digest it. There is a very simple reason for this, dogs and cats need a highly acidic stomach in order to properly digest their food BUT… The carbohydrates in processed foods make the stomach less acidic.
Note: Dogs naturally acidic stomachs are designed to eat meat, bones, tripe and organ.

Low-quality ingredients

Processed dog food is generally made using extremely low-quality ingredients. As explained elsewhere in this article, that means animal by-products and derivatives and low-quality grain.

It has been cooked

Processed food has been cooked. Cooking alters the food’s chemical structure, destroys much of its nutritional value and makes it extremely difficult for a dog to digest. A processed food diet, because it is cooked, forces the pancreas to work harder and to draw other enzymes from the bloodstream. This can leave a dog physically vulnerable because the enzymes in the blood are supposed to be protecting the body, not aiding digestion. A number of medical studies show that the pancreas enlarges on a diet of processed food. An enlarged organ means excessive function. Excessive function can lead to degeneration. It is a similar story when it comes to amino acids. Cooking at high temperatures alters the arrangement of these acids, making half of them unusable by the canine body.

Manufacturers try to persuade consumers that the canine digestive system has altered and can now accommodate cooked and processed food. Paleontologists estimate that a period of at least 100,000 years is required before evolutionary changes occur within a whole species. The most accepted theories estimate that dogs began their association with humans between 8,000 and 20,000 years ago. They haven’t, therefore, had time to adapt to eating cooked food let alone processed food, which has only been around since 1860!

In the case of kibble it is also too concentrated and too dry (less than 10% moisture compared to 70% moisture in a natural diet).

It contains grain

Grain is used a great deal in processed food as it is inexpensive and gives it bulk. Some food will contain up to 65% grain, although this may not be apparent on the label. In the wild less than 1% of a dog’s diet will be grain. There is a reason why one rarely sees a dog stalking a wheat or rice field. Complex carbohydrates (grains) that dogs eat just end up in an accumulation of lactic acids. Whereas humans can convert complex carbohydrates into sugars and store them for use later (this is what happens when one eats, say, porridge), dogs can’t do either. Most grain in processed dog food ends up going in one end and coming out the other.

This abnormal build-up of lactic acid can affect the cardiac system, including the heart and eventually all organ systems in the body.

Symptoms of Lactic Acid Build-Up in Dogs

Exercise intolerance
Muscle stiffness or soreness
Heavy breathing

It contains fiber

Processed food contains a high percentage of fiber, described as ‘crude fiber’ because it is of such low quality. In most cases the fiber takes the form of peanut hulls, almond shells, empty grain hulls, beet pulp and so forth. None of these things offers any nutritional value to dogs.

It contains preservatives

Chemical preservatives are added to keep the food from going off. Where there are no added preservatives, it is either because the food has been heated to such a high temperature that no preservatives are necessary or because the original ingredients already contained sufficient preservatives.

It contains artificial colouring

Dried and canned food is usually grey. For this reason food colouring is added to give it a more natural appearance. Many trainers believe that the artificial colouring is one of the causes of behavioral issues in dogs.

You will find that a raw fed dog is easier to train and has no behavioral issues.

It contains binders

In the manufacturing process many of the ingredients in dog food are rendered, that is to say they are heated until they turn into a liquid. In order to make it look like kibble or ‘chunks of meat’ chemical binders are added.

It contains unhealthy fats

Many commercial dog foods have fat sprayed on them as a way of making them palatable. Fat may also be added to improve nutritional value. The quality of this fat is usually poor. Fat can be recycled from deep fryers in restaurants and tallow that rises from rendering plants. It may be rancid.

To be honest, if this information does not put you off feeding your dog kibble then nothing will!


What about those healthy looking dogs on the TV commercials?

If the television commercials, advertisements and labelling are to be believed, processed food is the only safe thing to feed a dog. It contains nothing but natural goodness, has been scientifically formulated and is endorsed by experts, including vets. What’s more, if your dog is suffering from any particular ailment, there is almost certainly a food designed to put it right. Pet food manufacturers would have it that they are your dog’s best friend. After reading this article you may begin to feel otherwise. Indeed, you may conclude that you have been misled and deceived.

Doesn’t the law protect me and my dog from what the kibble manufacturers put in kibble?

There is a considerable volume of British and European legislation controlling the manufacture of dog food but it barely considers the health of the animals eating it. Its real purpose is to protect the human food chain. This quote taken from the guidance given to pet food manufacturers, demonstrates how little the government cares:

“For pets, the main part of the risk assessment when setting the maximum permitted levels for undesirable substances will generally be the extent to which the animal can tolerate them”

In other words, it is legal to use undesirable substances in dog food providing they don’t kill the animal immediately.

Another disturbing quote from the same guide refers to ingredients:

“The material of animal origin used by the pet food industry comprises those parts of animals which are either deemed surplus to human consumption or are not normally consumed by people, and derived from animals inspected and passed as fit for human consumption prior to slaughter. Animal material of this nature, which is not intended for human consumption, is classified as animal by-products under the EC Regulation”

As Ian Billinghurst, author of Give Your Dog a Bone, says:

“Our dogs’ disease problems are increasing on a par with their increasing consumption of processed and cooked foods … dog food manufacturers take useless waste from the human food industry and sell it as dog food. Why do they bother? Advertising implies that they are there to promote the health of dogs. Their primary concern is in fact profit. The laws which govern dog food production do not require it to promote health, reproduction, growth or longevity”

If one cares about dogs it is very easy to get worked up about the processed dog food industry. It is a scandal waiting to happen. The only difference between this situation and what occurred with tobacco, asbestos, powdered milk formula, fast food and all the other consumer campaigns that have led to major changes is that the victims of the processed dog food industry can’t speak for themselves.

It’s all about profit

It isn’t just that the legislation doesn’t consider canine health; it is entirely skewed in the manufacturers’ favour. As you can see from the quotes above, they can put in almost any ingredient they want (providing it doesn’t actually poison the dog) and can be misleading in what they tell consumers. How did this happen? Since the industry came into being, manufacturers have managed to persuade both the public and legislators that they are experts and can be trusted. They have used clever marketing techniques and veterinary endorsements to great effect and have been much aided by consumer demand for convenience.

It also helps that for many years the industry has been dominated by five multinational corporations, which between them control around 80% of the worldwide market. They are Nestlé’s (Purina, Bakers &c.), Del Monte (the Heinz range of pet foods), MasterFoods/Mars (Royal Canin, Pedigree &c.), Procter & Gamble (Iams, Eukanuba &c.) and Colgate-Palmolive (Hill’s Science Diet, Nature’s Best &c.).

These companies lobby hard to ensure that their business interests aren’t disturbed by unhelpful legislation. Their biggest single market is the USA, where pet food accounts for $15 billion a year. But the UK market is still sizeable with over £1 billion a year spent on dog food alone.

It isn’t just the overall size of the market that makes it so attractive to manufacturers. Processed dog food is incredibly profitable. As one commentator pointed out:

“What most consumers don’t realise is that the pet food industry is an extension of the human food and agriculture industries. Pet food provides a convenient way for slaughterhouse offal, grains considered unfit for human consumption and similar waste products to be turned into profit”

Life expectancy of dogs on kibble versus those on raw

There’s an Australian study (quoted by Mogens Eliasen) in which it was demonstrated that a dog’s life expectancy increased by 30% when fed a raw, natural diet. Dogs that normally were expected to live until age 12 maintained a healthy life until they were 16 years old. This rather implies that dogs fed a processed food diet are leading shorter lives.

I hope this article has given you some insight into processed dog food. At the end of the day it is your choice whether you want to feed your dog kibble or a balanced raw meat diet.

Bev, Mike & Monty (the meat eater) ♥